🛵 Wired But Vulnerable: Gig Workers Get a Legal Backbone in Karnataka

ECONOMY & REFORMS

Post Date: June 3, 2025
Focus: GS3 / Inclusive Growth / Labour Reforms

🌀 Intro Whisper

On the streets of every city, they race the clock, guided by maps and ratings — yet invisible in India’s labor laws. Karnataka’s bold new ordinance may finally put a frame around this blurry workforce.

🔍 Key Highlights

• ✅ Karnataka Platform-Based Gig Workers (Social Security and Welfare) Ordinance, 2025 introduces India’s most comprehensive legal framework to protect platform-based gig workers.
• 🏛️ Mandates creation of a Gig Workers Welfare Board with wide powers over registration, grievance redressal, and welfare contribution collection.
• 🧾 Registration of both workers and platforms made mandatory; gig workers will receive a unique ID and recognition within the state welfare ecosystem.
• 💰 Platforms (like Ola, Swiggy, Amazon, Zomato) to contribute 1–5% of payouts to a state-run social security fund.
• 📜 Written contracts, algorithm transparency, and a two-tier grievance system to regulate exploitative practices and opaque rating systems.

🧭 Concept Explainer: Who Are Gig Workers?

Section 2(35) of the Code on Social Security, 2020 defines gig workers as:

“A person who participates in a work arrangement and earns from such activities outside of a traditional employer–employee relationship.”

Unlike salaried employees, gig workers:

• Have no fixed income, no job security, and no benefits like PF, gratuity or leave.
• Are often governed by opaque algorithms that assign tasks and determine pay.
• Are excluded from traditional labor protections — until now.

📊 Data Snapshot: The Gig is Growing (Source: NITI Aayog / Borzo)

📉 77.6% earn less than ₹2.5 lakh/year
📉 Only 2.6% earn above ₹5 lakh/year

🧱 Key Features of the Ordinance

📚 GS Paper Mapping

• GS Paper 3 – Economy & Labour Reforms
  • Future of work & informal sector regulation
  • Digital economy and inclusive growth
  • Labour code implementation
  • Social protection for platform-based workers

💡 A Thought Spark — by IAS Monk

“In a world run by codes and customer stars, this law offers the gig worker something rare — a name, a number, and a seat at the table.”

High Quality Mains Essay For Practice :

Word Limit 1000-1200

The Future of Gig Work in India: Between Flexibility and Fragility

Introduction

The 21st-century workforce is increasingly defined by flexibility, autonomy, and technology-enabled disruption. Nowhere is this shift more visible than in the rise of gig and platform-based work — a form of employment where individuals earn income by providing services via digital platforms without formal employer-employee relationships. From food delivery agents to app-based cab drivers and freelance content creators, gig workers have become the backbone of India’s urban service economy.

Yet, while this form of work promises flexibility and innovation, it often delivers precarity and invisibility. The passing of the Karnataka Platform-Based Gig Workers (Social Security and Welfare) Ordinance, 2025 is a timely intervention in this fast-growing, yet largely unregulated sector. This essay explores the rise of gig work in India, the socioeconomic dynamics that shape it, challenges faced by workers, global comparisons, and the reforms necessary to build a fair and secure digital labor future.

1. Understanding Gig and Platform-Based Work

Gig work refers to task-based, short-term jobs done by individuals, often mediated by digital platforms. The Code on Social Security, 2020, defines a gig worker as one who earns outside a traditional employer–employee relationship.

There are two broad categories:

• Gig Workers: Perform short-term assignments (e.g., graphic designers, photographers).
• Platform Workers: Work through tech platforms (e.g., Uber, Swiggy, Urban Company) that assign and monitor tasks.

The attraction lies in flexibility, low barriers to entry, and the growing demand for convenience. But this model masks profound asymmetries in control, risk, and reward.

2. Data Snapshot: The Gig Economy Boom

According to a NITI Aayog report:

• India had 7.7 million gig workers in 2021.
• By 2024, this is estimated to rise to 20 million.
• By 2030, it may reach 23.5 million, forming 4% of the total workforce.

Income-wise:

• Only 2.6% earn more than ₹5 lakh annually.
• A staggering 77.6% earn less than ₹2.5 lakh a year.

This data reveals that while gig work is growing, it remains largely low-income, insecure, and under-regulated.

3. Why Gig Work is Rising in India

Several structural and social factors fuel this rise:

• Formal Job Deficit: India’s youth face a dearth of formal employment despite educational expansion.
• Urban Service Demand: App-based food delivery, ride-sharing, and logistics have boomed.
• Smartphone Penetration: Affordable internet has made platform participation accessible.
• Low Entry Barriers: Gig work requires minimal qualifications or training.
• COVID-19 Disruptions: The pandemic hastened the shift toward contactless, on-demand services.

Gig work, then, is not merely a preference — it is increasingly a compulsion.

4. The Precarity of Gig Life

Behind the promise of freedom lies unfreedom — characterized by:

• Lack of Social Protection: No maternity leave, pension, insurance, or provident fund.
• Algorithmic Management: Workers are governed by opaque algorithms that assign tasks, determine pay, and impose penalties — all without human accountability.
• Absence of Representation: Gig workers often lack unions or collective bargaining rights.
• Unfair Ratings and Blocking: Workers can be blocked or downgraded based on client complaints, without appeal.
• No Guaranteed Income: Earnings vary based on platform policies, location, time, and demand — with no minimum guarantee.

Gig workers are independent only on paper; in reality, they are digitally managed employees without rights.

5. The Karnataka Ordinance: A Step Towards Protection

The Karnataka Gig Workers Ordinance, 2025, is the first serious legislative attempt in the state to address these vulnerabilities. Key provisions include:

• Formation of a Gig Workers Welfare Board.
• Mandatory registration of platforms and workers.
• Platforms to contribute 1–5% of total worker payouts to a Welfare Fund.
• Written contracts for transparency in earnings and blocking.
• Platforms must disclose algorithmic logic.
• Grievance redressal mechanisms via a two-tier system.
• Penalties for non-compliance: up to ₹1 lakh for repeated violations.

It reflects an important shift from “platforms as marketplaces” to “platforms as responsible employers.”

6. Other Initiatives Across India

• Social Security Code, 2020: Recognizes gig workers as a distinct category, mandates social security schemes.
• e-Shram Portal: National database for unorganized workers, including gig workers.
• Rajasthan Platform-Based Gig Workers Act, 2023: First state law with provisions for welfare fee contributions.
• Budget 2025-26: Extended Ayushman Bharat coverage and ID issuance for gig workers.

These initiatives signal a growing realization that gig work is not temporary, but the new normal — and requires regulatory innovation.

7. International Approaches to Gig Worker Rights

Globally, the classification of gig workers remains controversial. Key models include:

• United Kingdom: After a Supreme Court ruling, Uber drivers were recognized as “workers” entitled to minimum wage and holiday pay.
• European Union: Proposing legislation that presumes employment unless the platform proves otherwise.
• United States: California’s Assembly Bill 5 sought to classify many gig workers as employees, but faced industry pushback.

India’s path will likely involve creating a third category — neither fully employee nor contractor, but with specific legal safeguards.

8. Challenges to Regulation

• Platform Resistance: Tech companies argue that regulation stifles innovation and raises costs.
• Implementation Capacity: State welfare boards may lack infrastructure and data accuracy.
• Worker Awareness: Many gig workers are unaware of their rights or lack documentation.
• Urban Bias: Rural gig workers (e.g., in digital freelance work) remain excluded.
• Lack of Collective Voice: Gig worker unions are still weak, though growing in cities like Bengaluru and Delhi.

Thus, legislation is only a first step. Execution, enforcement, and worker empowerment are key.

9. The Ethical & Economic Imperative

Gig workers are integral to the urban economy, providing essential services while absorbing the shocks of informalization. Protecting their rights is not charity — it is economic justice and social sustainability.

Moreover, gig platforms rely on network effects and monetize data generated by workers. Fair redistribution of value must be part of platform accountability.

Failing to regulate this space could deepen income inequality, erode dignity of work, and worsen India’s informal sector trap.

10. The Road Ahead

India must now build a Digital Labour Compact grounded in five principles:

1. Recognition: Legal status and identity for gig workers.
2. Representation: Right to unionize and negotiate.
3. Redistribution: Fair share of platform profits into welfare schemes.
4. Regulation: Transparent algorithms, standard contracts, and minimum wage policies.
5. Reskilling: Training and mobility pathways to formal careers.

Additionally, tech for welfare — using Aadhaar-linked DBTs, grievance dashboards, and worker-controlled apps — can enhance inclusivity.

Conclusion

The gig economy in India is both a promise and a paradox — it creates jobs but not security, offers autonomy but enforces algorithmic control. With 1 in 20 workers soon to be gig-based, the need to balance flexibility with fairness, innovation with inclusion, and growth with dignity has never been greater.

The Karnataka Ordinance is a commendable first move. But the larger task lies ahead: to ensure that the worker behind the app notification is not just a nameless driver or anonymous delivery agent, but a citizen with rights, a laborer with protection, and a human being with dignity.

Target IAS-26: Daily MCQs :

📌 Prelims Practice MCQs

Topic: Gig Workers